BOSTON (WGGB/AP) — State energy regulators have fined three Massachusetts utilities nearly $25 million for “systematic and fundamental failures” in their response to two major storms in 2011.
The penalties were announced Tuesday by the Department of Public Utilities after an investigation that took more than a year.
Some customers were without power for a week after Tropical Storm Irene in August 2011 and a surprise October snowstorm.
National Grid was fined a total of $18.7 million; NStar was fined $4.1 million and Western Massachusetts Electric Co. was fined $2 million.
The fines are a bit less than the nearly $30 million recommended by Attorney General Martha Coakley.
The utilities can appeal.
Under a new state law passed this year, the fines will be returned to consumers in the form of rate relief.
In response to the fines issued Tuesday, National Grid had this statement:
“We understand customers were frustrated by the outages resulting from the devastating storms in 2011 and we share that frustration. We have implemented many changes to our emergency planning and put these into practice during Hurricane Sandy and the November nor’easter. We welcome the opportunity to review our emergency response procedures to continuously improve our service to customers during emergency events and will work closely with the DPU auditors in that review process. We have not yet had an opportunity to fully review and evaluate the Department’s order. We will need some time to evaluate the order fully to consider our options going forward. In the meantime, we will continue to remain focused on providing the level of service our customers deserve and expect.”
Western Mass. Electric says that the company continuously updated customers and local and state officials on the restoration progress. They add that in Tuesday’s ruling, the state noted that WMECo followed their emergency plan, but say they levied fines “for response times to municipal requests for assistance, which were not regulated by the [response] plan.”
In a statement, WMECo says that they intend to appeal the fine, and company president Peter Clarke adds:
“We strongly disagree with the DPU’s finding and are disappointed they have chosen to take this path. We had hoped the department would follow the evidence showing our response properly addressed priorities created by the storm. The men and women of WMECO worked tirelessly to restore power to our customers affected by the worst storm impact in our 100-plus year history. We commend them for their diligence and dedication to getting the job done in extremely difficult conditions.”







so stupid…
Here comes another rate increase, smh.
Unbelievable! I think the response, given what they were dealing with was fine – not to mention way to stick it to the customer. They will have no choice but to pass this fee on via higher rates!
There are only so many workers and trucks to fix thousands of wires and poles across the state
“Under a new state law passed earlier this year, the fines will be returned to consumers in the form of rate relief.” I’m very happy they got a big fine. A lot of elederly people & businesses really suffered
The problem with wmeco was poor people had to leave their homes with children to get hotels. Then they wanted their bill paid. Asked for a payment plan because I spent all I had for 7 days. They wouldn’t do it. Of course I would have paid them back, they would shut it off if I didn’t.
Force the state energy regulators live in South Florida during hurricane season to see what it’s really like to be without power for extended periods. I was without power twice in 2004, once for 10 days and once for 14 days. In one instance, it was the not so friendly guys on a Quebec Hydro truck that restored our power. The power will be back on when the power is back on.
I also think they did a great job. I was without power for 7 days. But there were also many roads around that were unpassable. Considering the scope of the situation, and the fact that, even though they predicted it would be a mess…I don’t think Anyone could have predicted how bad it was. And giving them a hefty fine does what? We get that fine as “rate relief”??? How about instead of fining them, we say…hey, use those fines to upgrade the system because the general population will gripe every time you need to raise the rates so you can improve your infrastructure.